Taylor Swift fans speculate Harry Styles is ‘lying traitor’ she sings about on new song as wild theories circulate about her and Dianna Agron

Taylor Swift has got fans talking after she branded an unnamed ex-boyfriend – thought to be Harry Styles – a ‘lying traitor’ in a new song.

The singer, 33, has dropped previously unreleased songs on the new version of her fifth album 1989 which took her career to new heights when it came out in 2014.

On one of the new songs, Is It Over Now, Taylor hits out at a former partner for being a ‘lying traitor’ and sleeping with a series of models after they broke up.

During the year she wrote 1989, Taylor famously dated Harry Styles along with Conor Kennedy, son of current US presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy – with both them thought to have inspired the record. 

Meanwhile, Taylor has also slammed rumours that she was romantically involved with any of her female friends on the new album after it was speculated she had a fling with Glee actress Dianna Agron.

Taylor Swift has got fans talking after she branded an unnamed ex-boyfriend a ‘lying traitor’ in a new song

On one new song, called ‘S**t!’, Taylor sings about the public backlash she received for dating an unnamed heartthrob, with many speculating it could be Harry.

She sings: ‘I will pay the price you won’t.

‘And if they call me a s**t, you know it might be worth it for once.

‘And if I’m going to be drunk I might as well be drunk in love.

‘He’s waiting there. The sticks and stones they throw froze midair.’

She continues: ‘Everyone wants him, that was my crime.

‘The wrong place at the right time . . . I break down and he’s ­pulling me in.

‘In a world of boys, he is a gentleman.’

Taylor and Harry Styles in 2012. On one of her new songs, she hits out at a former partner for being a 'lying traitor' - and fans think it could be him

Taylor and Harry Styles in 2012. On one of her new songs, she hits out at a former partner for being a ‘lying traitor’ – and fans think it could be him

She has also slammed rumours that she was romantically involved with any female friends following speculation that she had a fling with Glee actress Dianna Agron (pictured)

She has also slammed rumours that she was romantically involved with any female friends following speculation that she had a fling with Glee actress Dianna Agron (pictured)

Along with Harry, Taylor has also dated DJ Calvin Harris, guitarist John Mayer, film star Jake Gyllenhaal, actor Joe Alwyn and The 1975’s Matty Healy. She is currently in a relationship with American footballer Travis Kelce.

On the prologue for 1989 (Taylor’s Version), Taylor recalls how she tried to avoid publicly being seen with any man to avoid speculation she was dating them.

She wrote: ‘It became clear that for me there was no such thing as casual dating or even having a male friend.

‘If I was seen with him, it was assumed I was sleeping with him. And so I swore off hanging out with guys. Dating.

‘Flirting or against anything that could be weaponised against me by a culture that claimed to believe in liberating women but constantly treated me with the harsh moral codes of the Victorian era.’ 

Several of Taylor’s fans took to social media to react to her newly-released songs, with one writing on X, formerly Twitter: ’22 year old Taylor Swift calling Harry Styles a lying traitor is my favourite thing in the world.’

Another wrote: ‘I would like to thank Harry Styles for breaking up with Taylor Swift and giving us the 1989 vault tracks’.

A third added: ‘Did Taylor Swift call Harry Styles before this and was like, “listen…ummmm”‘.

A fourth penned: ‘Taylor Swift actually devoured Harry Styles in the vault.’  

Several of Taylor's fans took to social media to react to her newly released songs

Several of Taylor’s fans took to social media to react to her newly released songs

In the mid 2010s, Taylor made headlines for hanging out with several female celebrities who became known as her ‘girl squad’.

They included Selena Gomez, Gigi Hadid, the Haim sisters, Blake Lively, Cara Delevingne and Hailee Steinfeld.

But that didn’t stop people from ‘sexualising’ those relationships either.

Taylor wrote: ‘If I only hung out with my female friends, people couldn’t sensationalise or sexualise that, right? I would learn later on that people could and people would.’ 

Dianna Agron has previously addressed speculation about her relationship with Taylor after the Glee star denied being in a love triangle with her and former NFL star Tim Tebow. 

Dianna denied there was any love triangle during a 2012 appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live and when the host asked her if there was a possibility of a romance with the singer, she replied: ‘Wouldn’t that be juicy?’

She then blew a kiss at the camera and said: ‘Hi Taylor.’ 

On the prologue for 1989 (Taylor's Version), Taylor recalls how she tried to avoid publicly being seen with any man to avoid speculation she was dating them

On the prologue for 1989 (Taylor’s Version), Taylor recalls how she tried to avoid publicly being seen with any man to avoid speculation she was dating them

Taylor is currently in a relationship with Kansas City Chiefs player Travis Kelce

Taylor is currently in a relationship with Kansas City Chiefs player Travis Kelce 

Dianna was asked again about speculation over a relationship with Taylor during a 2023 Rolling Stone interview.

She said: ‘That is so interesting. I… I mean, there have been many stories about my dating life that are so wildly untrue. That’s funny.’

Taylor was also rumoured to be romancing her friend Karlie Kloss after a grainy picture emerged on social media that appeared to show them kissing at a concert by The 1975 in 2014. 

At the time, a spokesperson for the performer was quick to nix the rumour to Gossip Cop, branding it ‘hilarious’.

In 2019, Taylor explicitly told Vogue she was not a part of the LGTBQ+ community, but was passionate about speaking up for it, adding: ‘I didn’t realize until recently that I could advocate for a community that I’m not a part of. 

After years of remaining silent over theories that she had a romantic relationship with her former best friend Karlie Kloss, the singer alluded to the persistent rumours as she called out the public for sexualising her female friendships

After years of remaining silent over theories that she had a romantic relationship with her former best friend Karlie Kloss, the singer alluded to the persistent rumours as she called out the public for sexualising her female friendships

‘It’s hard to know how to do that without being so fearful of making a mistake that you just freeze. Because my mistakes are very loud. 

‘When I make a mistake, it echoes through the canyons of the world. It’s clickbait, and it’s a part of my life story, and it’s a part of my career arc.’

The musician also addressed her reason for surrounding herself with friends in her mid-twenties as an attempt to ‘make up for a lack of them in childhood’ not to start a ‘tyrannical hot girl cult’. 

In the prologue for 1989 (Taylor’s Version), she also praised listeners and fans for seeing ‘the seeds of allyship and advocating for equality’ in her track, Welcome To New York, in which she sings: ‘Everybody here was someone else before/And you can want who you want/Boys and boys and girls and girls.’ 

Harry Styles’s A-list love life! MailOnline charts his high-profile relationships 

Taylor Russell, 29

Summer 2023-present 

Harry's relationship with his girlfriend, Taylor Russell, is getting pretty serious

Harry’s relationship with his girlfriend, Taylor Russell, is getting pretty serious

Harry’s relationship with his girlfriend, Taylor Russell, is getting pretty serious.

The 29-year-old Watermelon Sugar singer reportedly ‘sees a future’ with the Bones And All actress, 29, and their romance is heating up since the pair started dating over the summer.

‘Harry is head over heels for Taylor,’ a source revealed to Us Weekly, before noting that he ‘loves spending as much time with her as he can’.

The insider claimed: ‘Things are very serious, and Harry definitely sees a future with Taylor.’

The happy couple were first romantically linked just months earlier when they were spotted leaving London’s White Cube art gallery together.

At the time, the pair were seen enjoying a romantic stroll through the city while holding hands.

The following month, Russell showed her support for her new beau at his Love On Tour concert stop in Vienna, Austria. 

Olivia Wilde, 39

Autumn 2020-November 2022

Styles and Olivia Wilde (pictured in London in March 2022) met on the set of Don't Worry Darling after Styles was cast in a lead role and Wilde directed the film

Styles and Olivia Wilde (pictured in London in March 2022) met on the set of Don’t Worry Darling after Styles was cast in a lead role and Wilde directed the film

Harry and Olivia Wilde met in September 2020 when he was cast in her film Don’t Worry Darling. At the time, Wilde was engaged to her partner of around a decade, Jason Sudeikis, with whom she shares two children.

Two months after Harry was cast in the movie, Wilde and Sudeikis announced their engagement had ended. At the time the announcement was made, a source claimed the pair had been separated since the beginning of 2020.

People reported that the source said: ‘[The split has] been amicable and they’ve transitioned into a great co-parenting routine. The children are the priority and the heart of the family’s relationship.’

As filming continued on set, Wilde heaped praise on to her lead actor in interviews, making note of his lack of ‘toxic masculinity’.

She said: ‘It’s pretty powerful and kind of extraordinary to see someone in his position redefining what it can mean to be a man with confidence.’

By January 2021, the couple were spotted out and about holding hands for the first time, as they dressed in all their finery to attend the wedding of Styles’s agent in Montecito, California.

The pair continued to date and grew closer over the next two years, with Styles reportedly meeting Wilde’s children as the relationship became more serious. 

But in November 2022, just a few months after Don’t Worry Darling premiered in cinemas, the couple announced they were ‘taking a break’ from their relationship. 

A source told People: ‘He’s still touring and is now going abroad. She is focusing on her kids and her work in LA. It’s a very amicable decision.’

Camille Rowe, 33

Summer 2017-July 2018 

Styles dated French-born Victoria's Secret Angel Camille Rowe for about a year between the summer of 2017 and 2018 (pictured together in New York)

Styles dated French-born Victoria’s Secret Angel Camille Rowe for about a year between the summer of 2017 and 2018 (pictured together in New York)

Rowe is rumoured to have been the inspiration behind some of the songs on Styles's album Fine Line

Rowe is rumoured to have been the inspiration behind some of the songs on Styles’s album Fine Line

Styles and Victoria’s Secret model Camille Rowe dated for around a year between the summer of 2017 and July 2018.

Although the pair never publicly confirmed their romance, they were reported to have met through their mutual friend Alexa Chung.

After their romance came to light, Harry and Camille were spotted on a string of occasions together, including a sushi date.

The French beauty also turned out to lend her support at his concerts, including one she attended with her mother, Anne Twist.

Following the couple’s split, Harry hinted during a promotional tour for his album Fine Line that some of the tracks on the record had been inspired by the romance.

Some fans suggested one of the lines in the song Falling hinted that Styles had been unfaithful to Rowe, referring to the lyrics: ‘I’m in my bed and you’re not here. And there’s no one to blame but the drink and my wandering hands.’

In another song, dubbed Cherry, Harry appeared to mock Camille’s new love interest art collector Theo Niarchos, whose father Philip owns an extensive art collection. 

Harry sings, ‘Don’t you call him “baby”, we’re not talking lately. Don’t you call him what you used to call me’, before adding, ‘Does he take you walking round his parents’ gallery?’

Tess Ward, 33 

2017

Harry Styles in 2017

Tess Ward wearing the exact same shirt Styles owned

The pair were linked in 2017 and Tess appeared to fuel romance rumours by stepping out in the exact same Gucci shirt as the former X Factor star

Styles and food blogger Tess Ward reportedly shared a ‘whirlwind romance’ in 2017, with rumours of the relationship flying when Ward was spotted wearing what appeared to be Styles’s shirt.

Despite keeping their romance under wraps, it appeared to be over before it had even begun as the pair soon decided to spend time apart.

A source told The Sun at the time: ‘Harry and Tess haven’t seen each other for a number of weeks.’

The insider added: ‘Tess realised she still had feelings for her ex after splitting from him to date Harry and has apologised to him for her romance with the singer.

‘She was in London this week and met her ex straight away — they’ve been inseparable since.’ 

Speaking to The Times during the time the pair were rumoured to be dating, Ward revealed she had been forced to delete several of her social media accounts after receiving hate mail, leaving her solely with Instagram, although she admitted she was beginning to resent that, too.

She explained: ‘At the moment, I’m getting a lot of direct messages there, but I respectfully chose not to reply to them, because they’re all… interesting. I want a break!’

Dubbing the hate messages ‘very bizarre’, she reasoned: ‘I’m not the kind of person who’s interested in fame and if you’re put in an environment which you don’t understand and you can’t control and you don’t want, it’s horrible.’

Refusing to stoke the flames, when asked outright if she was dating Harry, Tess sighed: ‘I literally don’t have anything to say about that.’

Sara Sampaio, 31

2015

Victoria's Secret Angel Sara Sampaio was rumoured to have had a brief fling with Styles after they were spotted partying together in New York in 2015

Victoria’s Secret Angel Sara Sampaio was rumoured to have had a brief fling with Styles after they were spotted partying together in New York in 2015

Styles was rumoured to be dating Victoria’s Secret model Sara Sampaio in 2015 after the pair were spotted partying in Manhattan one evening, and pictured saying goodbye outside Sampaio’s hotel.

However, The Sun reported at the time that the Portuguese model later returned to the hotel, and emerged again the next morning around 11am, wearing the same clothes as the night before. 

‘There was definitely chemistry there as they hugged and kissed each other when she left but everyone thinks something was up as she came back and they left so soon after each other the next morning,’ a source told the newspaper. 

‘Sara left at 11am dressed exactly the same. Then Harry walked out at 11.15am and it looked like he’d been partying pretty hard.’

Georgia Fowler, 30

2015

New Zealand-born Victoria's Secret Angel Georgia Fowler sparked romance rumours with Styles when she posted a snap of the pair playing Scrabble

New Zealand-born Victoria’s Secret Angel Georgia Fowler sparked romance rumours with Styles when she posted a snap of the pair playing Scrabble

Another Victoria’s Secret Angel rumoured to have shared a romance with Styles is New Zealand-born model Georgia Fowler.

Fowler first sparked romance rumours with the singer after posting a sweet photo on her Snapchat page of Styles playing Scrabble with her while dressed in a hoodie.

Little is known about the couple’s reported romance as they remained tight-lipped in public about their relationship, however Fowler did her best to shut down rumours that one of the songs on Styles’s debut solo album was about her.

After fans buzzed around the lyrics to the song Kiwi, she was asked on Australia’s The Morning Show if the tune was about her.

The song features the curious lyric: ‘I think she said, “I’m having your baby, it’s none of your business”.’ 

Presenter Kylie Gillies asked: ‘Harry Styles, on his album has a song called Kiwi, can you confirm or deny that it was named after you?’

‘Ah, don’t really know anything about it,’ said Georgia, shaking her head, after referring to Harry as a ‘friend’.

She quickly added: ‘Definitely don’t have a baby… that’s what the song is all about.’

Kendall Jenner, 27

2013, 2014, 2016

Styles had an on-again, off-again romance with supermodel and member of the Kardashian clan Kendall Jenner

Styles had an on-again, off-again romance with supermodel and member of the Kardashian clan Kendall Jenner

Another of Styles’s whirlwind romances was with supermodel and member of the Kardashian family Kendall Jenner.

The pair reportedly got close when Styles was 21 and Jenner was 18, but the long-distance relationship did not last.

After about three months of dating, a source told The Sun the pair had called time on their relationship.

At the time, Styles had already had a string of high-profile relationships, however Kendall had reportedly only been involved with her high school boyfriend Julian Brooks.

A source told The Sun the pair had separated so they could focus on work and that there were no hard feelings between them.

They said: ‘There’s been no major fallout. They’re definitely still friends ad haven’t ruled anything out in the future.’ 

Despite calling time on their romance in 2014, the pair were spotted getting cosy on a yacht in St Barts early in 2016 after ringing in the new year together.

Photos showed the pair nuzzling into each other as they lay out on the sun deck surrounded by friends. 

Shortly afterwards, the pair went their separate ways once again, but they appear to have remained friends as Jenner has been spotted at Styles’s concerts supporting her ex in recent years.

Taylor Swift, 33

2012

Styles was spotted out and about with singer Taylor Swift in late 2012 and early 2013 before the pair called time on their romance just days after ringing in the new year (pictured December 2022 in New York)

Styles was spotted out and about with singer Taylor Swift in late 2012 and early 2013 before the pair called time on their romance just days after ringing in the new year (pictured December 2022 in New York)

Between 2012 and 2013, Styles and singer Taylor Swift had a three-month fling before the pair were reported to have split shortly after the new year following an ‘almighty row’.

Little more than a week after a very public display of affection on New Year’s Eve as the clock struck midnight to kick off 2013, a source confirmed to MailOnline that Styles and Swift had parted ways.

The source said: ‘Yes, I can confirm they have split up. They were on holiday and had an almighty row. They are two young stars at the top of their game, so who knows what will happen in the future.’

Swift, who is known to write songs about past relationships, is thought to have penned at least three songs about Styles – I Knew You Were Trouble, Style and Out Of The Woods.

In 2015, the singer revealed her whirlwind romance with Styles had been an experience filled with anxiety.

During a performance at the Grammy Museum, she introduced Out Of The Woods by telling the audience about an anxiety-inducing relationship – although she didn’t mention Styles by name. 

‘I’m going to play you a song that I wrote about a relationship that I was in that the number one feeling I felt in the whole relationship was anxiety,’ she explained as she sat at her piano.

‘Because it felt very fragile, it felt very tentative. And it always felt like, “Okay, what’s the next road block? What’s the next thing that’s gonna deter this? How long do we have before this turns into just an awful mess and we break up? Is it a month? Is it three days?”‘

Caroline Flack, died aged 41 in 2020 

2011

After meeting when Styles was a contestant on The X Factor and Flack was a host of spin-off show The Xtra Factor, the pair dated for three months (pictured in London in 2011)

After meeting when Styles was a contestant on The X Factor and Flack was a host of spin-off show The Xtra Factor, the pair dated for three months (pictured in London in 2011)

The late TV presenter Caroline Flack met Styles when he was a contestant with One Direction on The X Factor and she was host of spin-off show The Xtra Factor.

With a 15-year age gap – as Styles was 17 and Flack was in her early 30s at the time – the couple saw their romance come under harsh criticism from outsiders, which no doubt added to the decision to call time on their relationship after only three months. 

However, the pair only ever had good things to say about each other and defended their romance in the face of criticism.

Following their split, the pair remained full of praise for each other, with Styles pouring cold water on rumours about the break-up on Twitter.

He tweeted: ‘Please know I didn’t “dump” Caroline. This was a mutual decision. She is one of the kindest, sweetest people I know.’

Caroline Flack passed away in February 2020 after taking her own life. 

Leave a Comment